PCB design tools

There has been previously a sticky thread "Stop the is xxx software is better than xxx software topicz"

The author explained it as follows: Please do not start any more of these topics unless you have specific questions or object for comparing between the software. In other words no GENERIC statements, give specific question and ONLY give specific answers based on your own experience with the tools. These type of replies which only say 'i agree' or 'xxx is better I think' are actually no better than spam because all you are asking for is an un-informed opinion.

If you have SPECIFIC questions like
EDA vendor A software cannot do 'function type', How is this done in EDA vendor B software. Then we will get usefull information and comparison.

The above thread is a bit too general, I think.

I agree with FvM.
If you compare ( preferably by doing a real design) all the PCB packages, you will find they all have positive and negative points... Cost of ownership can be determined by getting quotes from the vendors. How a tool performs, depends how well it is used... Personally, myself I miss the halcyon days of tape ups, a scalpel instead of a mouse.

What about Kicad?

It sits with your requirements and use budget. Considering you have high requirements and budget; it is preferable to go through the trial period of all the software to make sure with what you are most compatible. In technical terms there are factors such as compatibility, ease of use, customer support and update requirements that need to be checked before finalizing any software.